http://washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A33912-2001Apr18.html

Analysis 
Heeding Economic Danger Signs

By Steven Pearlstein
Washington Post Staff Writer
Thursday, April 19, 2001; Page A01 



With its surprise rate cut yesterday, the Federal Reserve Board implicitly acknowledged that the collapse in corporate investment and rising unemployment could leave the U.S. economy stuck in neutral for the next year, or even tip it into recession.

Recent economic data show that the downturn in the manufacturing sector of the old economy, which began quietly last summer, has largely run its course. There are early signs that many businesses have worked off much of the excess inventories of cars and other durable goods that had built up during the heady days of 2000.

These positive developments have led a number of analysts to conclude that the economy is beginning to turn back up again.

"It got very dicey there, but we're staring to move ahead again," declared Martin Regalia, chief economist for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. Like many forecasters, he sees economic growth rates returning to 2 percent or more by the end of the year.

But to many other analysts, there remains a serious risk that the downturn is merely entering a new phase.

"We're in a much more dangerous phase right now," said Bruce Kasman, an economist at J.P. Morgan. "This economy is right on the edge."

Kasman and others note that the epidemic of falling sales and profits that swept through the manufacturing sector has now spread to the high-tech and service sectors of the new economy -- to telecommunications, software, entertainment and financial services -- that had provided much of the growth in jobs and wealth in the 1990s.

At the same time, they fear that American consumers, who have continued to spend and borrow at record levels, will finally pull back as the unemployment rate rises toward 5 percent, as many forecasters predict.

"I see huge risks for the economy right now," said Janet L. Yellin, a former Federal Reserve governor who now teaches at the University of California at Berkeley. "I'm worried the economy won't and can't pick up because of the enormous overcapacity in so many sectors and the weak investment climate going forward. And on the consumer side, we haven't seen the full impact yet from the fall in stock prices" from last year's peaks.

William Dudley, chief U.S. economist at Goldman Sachs Group Inc., is equally apprehensive. "I'm more concerned than ever that there is a long investment bust ahead of us that is already beginning to slow job growth and consumer spending," he said yesterday. "It's not at all clear that we're out of the woods yet."

Yesterday's interest rate cut will help, particularly if it continues to buoy stock prices, as it did yesterday, and bolsters consumer confidence, which showed signs of slipping again early this month. But economists warn that lower rates have little impact on corporate investment. Those decisions tend to be driven by the level of business profits and the outlook for higher sales. Right now, most of those signs are pointing downward.

"What we're experiencing now is not so much a recession as a change in economic lifestyle," said Edward Leamer, director of the UCLA Forecasting Unit, who is among the few forecasters to have predicted the speed and extent of the current downturn. "We're moving from an economy supercharged by capital investment, a booming stock market and rising consumer debt to an economy that has none of those. And we're a long way from completing that adjustment."

Certainly that's the message from many of the country's biggest companies in recent days. 

On Tuesday, chipmaker Intel Corp. announced its sales would be down 9 percent -- justification enough to halt construction of a $120 million research facility in Austin, postpone a $500 million plant expansion in Massachusetts and put on ice a new $2 billion factory in Ireland.

On the same day, rival chipmaker Texas Instruments Inc. warned of a 20 percent revenue decline over the next three months. "The outlook is bleak," said the company statement, which also brought news of 2,500 layoffs on top of the 900 voluntary retirements negotiated earlier this year.

No reversal, however, has been more dramatic than that at Cisco Systems Inc., which briefly last year was the world's most valuable company. On Monday, however, chastened Cisco managers who had once assured investors that sales would grow 30 percent to 50 percent a year for as far as the eye could see disclosed that sales this quarter were now falling at the rate of 30 percent, with no indication of when growth would resume.

"This may be the fastest any industry our size has ever decelerated," said chief executive John Chambers, who compared it to a 100-year flood. And after scrambling to hire 5,000 workers between November and March, Chambers said, Cisco will now trim its payroll of 8,500 workers.

Cisco and other telecommunications equipment companies were the biggest beneficiaries of an unprecedented boom in spending by American businesses in new plants, equipment and software that was growing at an annual rate of 20 percent last year, accounting for between one-third and one-half of the economy's growth. Now, instead of pushing on the economic accelerator, capital expenditures are acting as a brake, with many analysts expecting they will fall 5 percent to 10 percent this year -- and double that for high-tech equipment.

But it's not just high tech. Three major airlines announced yesterday that they lost money during the first quarter as a result of rising fuel prices and falling business travel. It was the industry's first quarterly loss since 1993, and the industry leader, United Airlines, warned that early bookings signaled a second-quarter performance that will be even worse.

Earlier in the week, Gannett Co., the country's largest newspaper chain, reported that help-wanted advertising in its newspapers was down 14 percent in the first quarter -- and falling fast. "We are managing on the assumption that we are in a recession, or about to enter one," said Chairman Douglas H. McCorkindale.

The advertising falloff has also hit national television and radio networks, where revenue is reportedly down 10 percent to 15 percent so far this year. In recent weeks, layoffs have been announced at the New York Times; Dow Jones, owner of the Wall Street Journal; and the Internet-oriented Industry Standard. Even billboards in Times Square are going begging.

A number of consumer-goods companies are also cutting back. Eastman Kodak Corp. announced this week that it was firing 3,000 workers in response to falling film sales. "I thought things were under control, but I have to tell you, I see rough water ahead," said Chairman Daniel Carp, who warned that there was little likelihood of a rebound in the second half.

Things look much the same to executives at Black & Decker Corp. "There was the general feeling that the situation would improve by the middle of the year, but we don't see that happening," said spokeswoman Barbara Lucas.

Wall Street's investment houses are also beginning to feel the pinch. Bear Stearns & Co., Prudential Securities Inc. and Charles Schwab & Co. have already announced layoffs totaling 3,000. And with merger activity and initial stock offerings now at their lowest levels in a decade, analysts say the job cuts could go much higher.

Just as significant to the New York economy, however, would be the loss of the fat annual bonuses paid to Wall Street executives -- $13 billion last year -- that had kept a fair chunk of Manhattan's shops and restaurants in business, and provided incomes to an army of housekeepers, doormen, chauffeurs, dog walkers and real estate brokers.

The slowdown is also beginning to weigh heavily on the balance sheets of big banks. This week, Citigroup Inc., Bank of America Corp. and J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. announced they had recorded big increases in write-offs and reserves to cover losses and expected losses in their credit card and commercial lending portfolios. Although these bad-debt levels remain well below levels reached during real estate bust of the 1990-91 recession, federal regulators have recently issued warnings about the serious risks posed by the large number of syndicated, unsecured loans held by large banks, particularly those to the telecommunications industry.

While much of the debate among economists in recent months has centered on the question of whether all this will translate into an official recession, David Wyss of Standard & Poor's Corp. thinks that has largely become a semantic exercise. Whether the finally tally shows the economy shrank or grew by 1 percent, he said, is probably less significant than the fact there is no quick rebound in store.

"It's not going to be much of a bounce-back," Wyss said. "It's going to be more of a crawl-back."

In Berkeley, Yellin says she can see the changes in her graduate business students. "Last year, they were doing IPOs on their cell phones," she recalled. "Now, I find them very interested in macroeconomic forecasting and inventory cycles. There's been a huge change."



? 2001 The Washington Post Company